A Federal Judge Just Put a $15 Billion Price Tag on the New York Times' Journalism

0
A Federal Judge Just Put a $15 Billion Price Tag on the New York Times' Journalism

Fifteen billion dollars. That's the number sitting on the New York Times' legal tab after U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday ruled this week that Donald Trump's defamation lawsuit against the paper can move forward. The suit targets claims made in "Lucky Loser," a 2024 book by Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig that accused Trump of committing complex tax crimes.

The judge didn't mince around. He found that Trump "plausibly alleged" the two reporters "lacked adequate support" for the accusations they printed and sold to the public as fact.

Judge Merryday, a George H.W. Bush appointee sitting in the U.S. District Court in Tampa, Florida, didn't rubber-stamp the entire case. He dismissed Trump's claims related to two separate newspaper articles. But the core of the suit — the book-length accusation that Trump engaged in elaborate tax fraud — survived the Times' motion to kill it. That's the part that carries the $15 billion demand. That's the part heading to discovery.

Discovery is where this gets interesting. Discovery means the Times' internal communications, editorial decisions, fact-checking processes — or lack thereof — all become fair game. Every email between Buettner, Craig, and their editors about what they could actually prove versus what they decided to publish anyway. Every conversation about whether the claims in "Lucky Loser" had the sourcing to back them up.

The New York Times has spent decades wrapping itself in the First Amendment like a security blanket every time someone calls their reporting into question. The defense has always been the same: we're the press, we're protected, go away. A federal judge just looked at the specific claims in this book and said the protection doesn't cover accusations you can't support.

Penguin Random House, the publisher that put "Lucky Loser" on shelves, is named in the suit alongside the Times. They made a business decision to publish a book alleging that a sitting president committed tax crimes. Now they get to explain that decision under oath.

The Times' chief White House correspondent, Peter Baker, was also named in the original complaint. The paper will undoubtedly frame this as an assault on press freedom — they always do. But there's a difference between reporting and accusing someone of crimes you can't back up with evidence. That difference is what defamation law exists to sort out.

Consider the standard Merryday applied. He didn't rule that Trump was right. He ruled that Trump's claim — that two reporters wrote a book accusing him of crimes without adequate support for those accusations — was plausible enough to warrant a trial. The Times couldn't convince even a Bush-appointed judge that the case was frivolous on its face.

The paper that styles itself as the gold standard of American journalism now has to prove, in a courtroom, that it had the goods when it called someone a tax criminal. Not in an editorial board meeting. Not in a book review. In front of a judge, under rules of evidence, with $15 billion on the line.

That's $15 billion. With a B. The kind of number that makes legal departments lose sleep and editorial boards reconsider what "adequate support" actually means before they go to print.


Most Popular

Most Popular