Ted Hudacko had a court order. Obtained in 2020, it explicitly prohibited transgender surgeries or procedures on his child without his consent. The University of California San Francisco implanted a puberty-blocking device in his teenager anyway — subcutaneously, a histrelin implant — while Hudacko's ex-wife Christine Underhill provided the authorization he never gave.
The case is now sitting on the Supreme Court's desk.
Hudacko sued the UC Regents in 2023. The Ninth Circuit sided with the university, granting qualified immunity to the officials involved. On October 19, 2026, a stack of amicus briefs landed at SCOTUS urging the court to take the case. On November 18, UCSF filed its brief in opposition. The question before the justices isn't just whether one father's rights were violated. It's whether a university hospital can override a court order protecting those rights and then hide behind immunity when it gets caught.
The briefs don't mince around.
Partners for Ethical Care argued that "parental rights are not just the oldest and most fundamental right" recognized under the Constitution. The Thomas More Society went further, writing that qualified immunity "should not protect officials who spend months deciding to keep" a parent in the dark about irreversible medical decisions. America's Frontline Doctors and the American College of Pediatricians filed separately.
Dr. Quentin Van Meter, former president of the American College of Pediatricians and a practicing endocrinologist, called the hospital's actions "a clear breach of parental rights that should be appealed." He added a detail the gender-medicine lobby would prefer you not hear: "98% of the patients go on to opposite sex hormones" after puberty blockers. The implant wasn't a pause button. It was a on-ramp.
UCSF's defense rests on qualified immunity — the legal doctrine that protects government officials from lawsuits unless they violated "clearly established" rights. Justice Clarence Thomas has already questioned the scope of that shield in the university context. In Hoggard v. Rhodes, Thomas asked bluntly: "Why should university officers receive the same protection as police officers who make split-second decisions?"
That's the gap UCSF is trying to thread. A police officer deciding whether to use force in a volatile standoff gets qualified immunity because the situation demands instant judgment. A university hospital that spent months coordinating a minor's medical treatment while deliberately excluding a father with a court order on file is not making a split-second call. That's a process. Processes leave paper trails. Paper trails mean somebody knew.
The broader pattern is impossible to ignore. Across the country, gender clinics have operated on the assumption that an affirming parent is the only parent who matters. Courts, custody agreements, and the objections of the other parent become obstacles to route around rather than legal boundaries to respect. Hudacko v. UC Regents is what happens when one father refused to disappear quietly.
UCSF public relations director Jess Berthold and public affairs director Kristen Bole have represented the university's communications on the case, per The College Fix. The university's position, stripped to its essentials, is that its officials couldn't have known they were violating clearly established law.
There was a court order. It said don't do this without the father's consent. They did it anyway. The law was established enough to be written down by a judge.