Alejandro Arévalo has crossed the U.S.-Mexico border illegally seven times. He's been deported six. The first time, he paid a smuggler $900. By 2014, the going rate was $10,000. At some point, a reasonable person might look at that price curve and consider a different life plan.
CNN looked at that record and saw a hero.
On Sunday's edition of CNN's Newsroom, host Fredricka Whitfield introduced a segment on immigration enforcement under President Trump's second term with the kind of framing that tells you exactly where the story is going before the first quote lands. "Since President Trump took office in 2025 and rolled out a hardline immigration policy," Whitfield began, setting the stage for reporter Valeria León's package — a sympathetic profile of a man who has made a career out of getting caught.
León's report, as detailed by NewsBusters' Steve Malzberg, opens with the kind of line that would get flagged as parody if it weren't delivered with a straight face. "Alejandro Arévalo knows what it means to cross the US-Mexico border illegally," León narrated. "He tried seven times." That's not a sob story. That's a rap sheet with a thesis statement.
Arévalo himself described his first crossing with a casualness that undercuts CNN's victimhood framing more effectively than any editorial ever could. "They just crossed over, walking, right. I crossed over with my cousin's papers," he told the network. Document fraud on attempt one. By the time he landed in jail, he said, "the whole process of deportation is when everything started." Six deportations later, he now lives in Mexico City with his wife, Daisy Sevilla — a naturalized U.S. citizen — and says he's "given up hope" of returning.
The segment treated this as tragedy. A man who admitted on camera to using someone else's identity documents, who was removed from the country six separate times by a system that apparently kept giving him another chance, is presented as evidence that enforcement has gone too far.
Sevilla, Arévalo's wife, added her own concern about the current climate. "It is a bit scary because, for example, like my nephew, um, has to like literally carry" — referencing her nephew, a U.S. citizen with a medical condition, apparently now worried about encounters with immigration authorities. The implication being that lawful citizens are living in fear because the government is enforcing laws against people who've been deported six times.
The math on CNN's broader editorial posture isn't subtle either. Malzberg's analysis found that of 87 Trump-related headlines on Google News, 45 were negative. One was positive. One. The network that aired a sympathetic profile of a six-time deportee can't find a single immigration enforcement success worth covering straight.
The Biden administration recorded 11 million border encounters during its tenure. By mid-2024, an estimated 16 million unauthorized immigrants were living in the United States. Under Trump's second term, nearly one million people have been deported. Those are the numbers CNN's segment never provided — context that might complicate the narrative of a system that's simply too harsh.
Arévalo told CNN he's afraid to even visit the border region. "If I go there, I'm pretty sure the next morning, just by my appearance, I'll..." — he trailed off. A man deported six times is worried he might get deported again.
The system caught him seven times. CNN's complaint is that it worked.